Pastors of the Church (1782 - Present)

Rev. DAVID JEWETT - Installed January 2, 1782;  Deceased February 28, 1783. Buried Metcalf Cemetery, Winthrop
Rev. JONATHAN BELDEN - Ordained August 27, 1800; Resigned September 10, 1805
Rev. DAVID THURSTON - Ordained February 18, 1807; Resigned October 15, 1851. d. June 29, 1856. Buried, Metcalf Cemetery, Winthrop
Rev. RUFUS SAWYER - Ordained October 15, 1851; Resigned January 21, 1859
Rev. SAMUEL D. BOWKER -  Ordained October 16, 1860; Resigned October 13, 1863
Rev. THOMAS K. NOBLE - Ordained October 13, 1863; Resigned March 15, 1865
Rev. EDWARD P. BAKER - Called November 1, 1865; Resigned July 1, 1872~
Rev. RICHARD W. JENKINS - Ordained September 15, 1874; Resigned April 17,1876
Rev. WARREN F. BICKFORD - Ordained June 20, 1876; Resigned August 26, 1880
Rev. WILLIAM F. OBEAR - Installed October 19, 1881; Resigned September 8,1885
Rev. JAMES B. HAWES - Installed September 8, 1885; Resigned June 11, 1889
Rev. PERLEY J. ROBINSON - Installed June 11, 1889; Resigned October 16, 1890
Rev. CHARLES W. PORTER  - Acting Pastor from January 1, 1891 to May 6, 1894
Rev. GEORGE H. CREDEFORD - Installed November 14, 1894; Resigned April 1, 1898
Rev. ROBERT R. MORSON - Called July 5, 1898; Resigned January 1,1901
Rev. ARCHIBALD CULLENS - Called April 16,1901; Resigned May 4,1902
Rev. A. K. BALDWIN - Called July 17, 1902; Resigned June 1, 1905
Rev. CHARLES P. CLEAVES - Called October 2, 1905; Resigned September 30,1906
Rev. Charles F. SARGENT - Called March 26,1907; Resigned January 15,1913
Rev. FRANCIS H. BATE - Called April 9,1913; Resigned July 24,1914
Rev. HARRY TRUST - Called December 9, 1914; Resigned August 5, 1918
Rev. V. E. BRAGDON - Called September 20, 1918; Resigned May 16,1920
Rev. CHARLES F. SARGENT - Called May 8, 1922; Resigned June 2,1929
Rev. JOHNSON A. HAINES - Served as Acting Pastor for three months in 1926
Rev. HERBERT M. WORTHLEY - Called August 21, 1929; Resigned August 31,1931
Rev. GEORGE M. PEACOCK - Called October 20, 1931; Resigned April 30, 1935
Rev. DAVID JACK - Installed October 30, 1935; Resigned August 31, 1943
Rev. JOHN H. ALEXANDER - Called September 27, 1943; Ordained September 24, 1948; Resigned May 22, 1949
Rev. B. PAUL PARDY - Called September 1, 1949; Resigned October 31, 1951
Rev. GEORGE E.WHITTIER - Called December 2, 1951; Resigned September 1, 1959 (Interim Pastor until December 14, 1959)
Rev. EARLE E. CLIFFORD - Called December 14, 1959; Resigned September 1, 1963
WILLIAM F. HAMEL - Called December 18, 1963; Resigned March 4, 1965
EDGAR L. JONES - Called April 18, 1965; Resigned October 30, 1966
Rev. ROBERT HOTELLING - Interim Pastor from November 7, 1966 to September 24, 1967
Rev. SHANE ESTES - Called October 1, 1967; Resigned July 15, 1975
Rev ROBERT HOTELLING - Interim  Pastor from September 7, 1975 to October 25, 1975
Rev. STEPHEN W. HOLMES - Called October 26, 1975; Resigned February 15, 1980
Rev. ROBERT D. HOTELLING - Interim Pastor from February 24, 1980 to October 3 1980
Rev. RICHARD THOMPSON - Interim Pastor from November 2 1980 to April 5, 1981
Rev. EDGAR L. JONES - Called April 6 1981; Resigned January 9, 1994.
Rev. GENNIE FERRELL - Interim Pastor from January 25, 1994 to December, 1994
Rev. DAVID WIGLEY - Interim Pastor from January, 1995 to August, 1995
Rev. STEVEN HASTINGS - Called August 13, 1995; Resigned July 31, 2000
Rev. IAN "JACK" STEEVES - Interim Pastor from September 1, 2000 to October 28, 2001
Rev. KIMBERLY MURPHY - Called November 11, 2001; Resigned September 21, 2008.
Rev. KAREN JANUS - Interim Pastor from November 1, 2008 to May 31, 2010
Rev. Dr. ALICE ANDERMAN - Called June 1, 2010, Retired June 8, 2014 
Rev. CHRISTINA CATALDO - Called July 1, 2014